kuning
22-09-2008, 04:56 PM
Hi folks, I've been trolling around the forum for quite some time now and thought I'd start a thread to (hopefully) get some help from you guys. I'm a noob and just started learning about to LS types engine so please pardon my stupid statements/questions. *put flame suit on*
Here's the scenario:
Project
LSx swap (LS1/LS2/LS3) + T56 on a non GMH vehicle
Project Aim
Road-legal (engineer certf)
Reliable daily drive
Keep A/C, P/S.
Projected power output - ~300rwkw or high 200rwkw
Brake & suspension upgrade
Constraints
Engine + tranny budget = approx $10,000.00 (the cheaper the better :nyuk:)
Swap kit - Engine mount,tranny mount, clutch master cylinder,fuel pump,etc - available.
Engine Constraint
LS1.Not much of an issue. Wire throtle body fits well with the donor car, OEM ECU fits well with LS1's 24x reluctors wheel, abundant literature on LS1, LS1 modifications, parts readily available, and if I get stuck there are alot of workshops who are more than familiar with the LS1. However, the question is; would it be better to get a crate engine or buy a second hand engine then rebuild to spec accordingly -maybe through a engine builder/workshop-
I'm assuming, going with LS1 might/will be cheaper than the other two engine options depending on the engine specs.
How much would a brand new LS1 crate engine cost?
I have seen used engines advertised for roughly $3500. Does this sound about right?
LS2 and LS3. I saw Holmart has these engines up for sale. However, alternator needs to be relocated to LS1 type otherwise bonnet won't close.
58x reluctor wheel I heard that 58x tooth crank trigger will have an issue with the ECU. I'm not really familiar with this. Can anyone shed some light on this?
Drive by wire pedal.I'm assuming Aussies LS2 and LS3 ( as fitted on VZ and VE HSVs) also apply this drive by wire technology?
From research, I have found several solutions:
Buy GM LS2/LS3 harness which comes complete with new pedal -need to custom modify gas pedal bracket to the existing donor car-
Get engine from a builder to do 24x reluctor wheels, wire throtle body & LS1 harness to fit OEM ECU.
I'm not familiar with V8 workshops here in Australia (esp. Victoria), so do you think there will be workshop/ engine builder that will cater for this spec?
Overall, in your point of view, which engine do you think is suitable for this project?
ECU
I'm a total tool when it gets to ECU. What sort of ECU is available for these engine? From what I researched so far, OEM can be used for this project. Do we use GM OEM ECU such as the E38,40 and 67 here in Australia? Also, what are the difference? Are they engine specific?
Human Resource Constraint
My main objective for doing this swap is to learn more about car mechanics. I don't want to just go drive-in drive-out from a workshop but to know what's happening to the car during the process. Therefore, I'm looking for a mechanic/workshop who will be willing to have me around (I can help if need be) when working on the car and wouldn't mind me asking questions (read- pestering around). I'm no pro but have some basics =)
In summary, do you think this is a feasible project? Or am I just living an impossible dream?
Many thanks in advance. My apologies for the bad english, I'm still trying to learn english :smilesandbanana:
And oh, hope I don't get flammed for this thread :bow:
Cheers
Yans
EDIT: Mods, my apologies. Should've put this in technical sub-forum.
Here's the scenario:
Project
LSx swap (LS1/LS2/LS3) + T56 on a non GMH vehicle
Project Aim
Road-legal (engineer certf)
Reliable daily drive
Keep A/C, P/S.
Projected power output - ~300rwkw or high 200rwkw
Brake & suspension upgrade
Constraints
Engine + tranny budget = approx $10,000.00 (the cheaper the better :nyuk:)
Swap kit - Engine mount,tranny mount, clutch master cylinder,fuel pump,etc - available.
Engine Constraint
LS1.Not much of an issue. Wire throtle body fits well with the donor car, OEM ECU fits well with LS1's 24x reluctors wheel, abundant literature on LS1, LS1 modifications, parts readily available, and if I get stuck there are alot of workshops who are more than familiar with the LS1. However, the question is; would it be better to get a crate engine or buy a second hand engine then rebuild to spec accordingly -maybe through a engine builder/workshop-
I'm assuming, going with LS1 might/will be cheaper than the other two engine options depending on the engine specs.
How much would a brand new LS1 crate engine cost?
I have seen used engines advertised for roughly $3500. Does this sound about right?
LS2 and LS3. I saw Holmart has these engines up for sale. However, alternator needs to be relocated to LS1 type otherwise bonnet won't close.
58x reluctor wheel I heard that 58x tooth crank trigger will have an issue with the ECU. I'm not really familiar with this. Can anyone shed some light on this?
Drive by wire pedal.I'm assuming Aussies LS2 and LS3 ( as fitted on VZ and VE HSVs) also apply this drive by wire technology?
From research, I have found several solutions:
Buy GM LS2/LS3 harness which comes complete with new pedal -need to custom modify gas pedal bracket to the existing donor car-
Get engine from a builder to do 24x reluctor wheels, wire throtle body & LS1 harness to fit OEM ECU.
I'm not familiar with V8 workshops here in Australia (esp. Victoria), so do you think there will be workshop/ engine builder that will cater for this spec?
Overall, in your point of view, which engine do you think is suitable for this project?
ECU
I'm a total tool when it gets to ECU. What sort of ECU is available for these engine? From what I researched so far, OEM can be used for this project. Do we use GM OEM ECU such as the E38,40 and 67 here in Australia? Also, what are the difference? Are they engine specific?
Human Resource Constraint
My main objective for doing this swap is to learn more about car mechanics. I don't want to just go drive-in drive-out from a workshop but to know what's happening to the car during the process. Therefore, I'm looking for a mechanic/workshop who will be willing to have me around (I can help if need be) when working on the car and wouldn't mind me asking questions (read- pestering around). I'm no pro but have some basics =)
In summary, do you think this is a feasible project? Or am I just living an impossible dream?
Many thanks in advance. My apologies for the bad english, I'm still trying to learn english :smilesandbanana:
And oh, hope I don't get flammed for this thread :bow:
Cheers
Yans
EDIT: Mods, my apologies. Should've put this in technical sub-forum.