PDA

View Full Version : What are peoples thoughts on mods and ADR compliance (FI v N/A)



FrangaFry
31-07-2012, 09:42 PM
Hi folks, please don't crucify me if I sound silly (I'm not really sure what my question is here, so stay with me while I blunder around), but I am still a bit of a novice with this car mod scene and a recent conversation I had with a very reputable shop has got me thinking............

As all members on here, I am sure, are already aware, most of us who have modded cars/bikes/4wd's etc have the ever present threat of being slapped with a non compliance sticker (especially those who have very noticeable mods, such as a FI or other bonnet bling); Now, I know we all go into this scene with eyes wide open about 'compliance' and 'defect' notices and the RISK; And I know that if you drive like a nanna your risk of being pulled over is smaller, BUT, one day the bonnet could be lifted ....... for any reason, and boom you are stuck with a big bill trying to get everything back to a compliance level (exhaust? shocks/springs? Brakes? FI? etc).

Added to the above, I have just read another post on here where the current engine/brakes/exhaust etc replacement/upgrade compliance guidelines are available (interesting reading I thought, not that I understood it all, or most of it actually...... but,). This, in conjunction with the above and a conversation I had the other day with said 'reputable shop' has got me thinking that FI may not be the way to go, especially given the over zealous nature of our law makers and enforcers in regards to modded cars and us 'hoons' (tongue in cheek........ I'm a crusty o'l enthusiast.... *grin*).

So I suppose I am looking for your thoughts on where the current 'climate' in regards to the above is taking us and how this has made you think about your current or future mods.

My current thoughts are that you seem to have more 'latitude' with N/A mods (the link: "http://www.infrastructure.gov.au/roa.../vsb_ncop.aspx" seems to indicate this....) than you would with FI mods to your donk (other mods aside, just speaking about engine mods here).

Given all of the above, and the recent mods I have done with my ride (nothing over the top, but a good strong FI package), I am now rethinking what my future options are.

Here is one I will throw out there and I would love to get your opinions.

I have a relatively new HTV1900 inter cooled package (I have done about 8,000km since it was installed new) and an LS1 (with springs and upgraded fuel system) that has done about 154,000km (PD, springs and fuel went on 8,000km ago - about 5 months ago now). I have been gathering brownie point and some cash over the last few months and will soon'ish... have enough cash to consider some more work (between 5k - 8k ... I hope *grin*). I was considering what to do about my bottom end given FI as I want to get longevity out of my engine and not just max power - I have 310rwk at the moment (and have also upgrade most other areas of my ride) and this is nice, maybe a bit more kw/toque but with the emphasis on 'confidence' of no failures.

Now, I am prone to the odd 'panic' and the above thread is one I am having at the moment ............. *grin*

So, should I continue down the FI path and forge/strengthen the bottom end (will 5 - 8k get the job done for this?), or should I bite the bullet, sell the PD (what do you think the market rate is for one of these at the moment ........ be nice please....) and add the 5 - 8k to the sell price of the PD and build an LS1 stroker (with a mild, not wild, cam) - I must admit I love what it is the PD does though and it will be hard to replicate in an N/A version.... adn still be nice to drive (which my wagon currently is)


So enough rambling, I am sure you get the drift of where I am coming from and would love to hear from the 'learned' on this one.

Cheers,

timy
31-07-2012, 10:14 PM
I would keep the charger.. The likely hood of being pulled over because of a stroker engine is way higher.. Any police officer who has heard one would know pretty quickly and they're not that easy to go 'under the radar'..
I dont think many police officers would even know what a top mount charger looks like (I convinced a female officer that my car was a v6 when I was on my p plates)... Although they know when a car is to loud..

With ur money I would save a little more, but an ls3 or 6ltr and chuck the charger back on.. Brand new motor with new charger, will be nice and quiet whenu like with that little bit more go.

Timy

bozodos
31-07-2012, 11:09 PM
wow cops have xray vision these days!? :P


I was under the impression that most PD kits were engineered when you buy them these days? Biggest issue is the insurance company IMO.

Xjas
01-08-2012, 02:08 AM
Going NA is not what it seems either, if you are having the car engineered the engineer may have you get the car emission tested, FI cars can usually get passed if tuned properly with good cats and big mufflers, any decent cammed car would have a lot of trouble passing a emision test due to the cam overlap.

Angeldust
01-08-2012, 07:45 AM
Question.

If i go to a reputable workshop, and get a 'drive in and out' package (supercharger), will my car be legal? ie./ will the car be legally complienced becasue the 'kit' is complienced
or will i have to go to another mob for engeeners certification etc to make it legal?



SO far i have kept my car as stock as possible to avoid any hassle from police. (only exhaaust+ tune, suspecnsion and wheels stock) and the leaglities of things have held
me back from doing any more.

whitels1ss
01-08-2012, 08:27 AM
I dont think many police officers would even know what a top mount charger looks like (I convinced a female officer that my car was a v6 when I was on my p plates)...
That would have been funny mate:goodjob:

Was she a blonde? :stick::jester:

timy
01-08-2012, 09:01 AM
Hahaha yeah she was, I played the whole 'daddy bought it for me, and he wouldn't have got it for me if it was illegal'..

She then pretended she knew what she was looking for in the engine bay and told me I was free to go lol..

FrangaFry
01-08-2012, 09:44 AM
Question.
If i go to a reputable workshop, and get a 'drive in and out' package (supercharger), will my car be legal? ie./ will the car be legally complienced becasue the 'kit' is complienced or will i have to go to another mob for engeeners certification etc to make it legal?

My understanding is that none of these after market FI packages are certified compliant regardless of who installs. As some one else has pointed out, engineering cert and ADR/EPA are totally separate.

whitels1ss
01-08-2012, 10:22 AM
My understanding is that none of these after market FI packages are certified compliant regardless of who installs. As some one else has pointed out, engineering cert and ADR/EPA are totally separate.
What about the "Streetfighter" packages from KPM Motorsport with full warranty?
Surely they are legal?:confused:

white lie
01-08-2012, 10:38 AM
I think you worded it a little wrongly.
The kit itself has no compliance but upon request with your installer they may 'legalize' it for an additional cost.

I know the thread you've been reading and think it has made you a little paranoid. I also think the information in there is outdated. Loads of turbo, twin turbo and supercharged V8's over here that are all fully permitted and legal that are bigger than 5.4L in capacity as according to that thread.
In WA, you have to apply in principal before conducting any modifications. If your plan doesn't meet the criteria (ie has no way of passing) then approval is denied.

In regards to the stroker comment above, what if a stock exhaust is slapped on it to quieten it down? What if you just slotted in a head and cam LS3? Would make more power than he's currently making and will just sound like a cammed LS1. Quite easy to get that passed over here if the right cam is chosen, especially when comparing it to a cammed/blown combo.

whitels1ss
01-08-2012, 11:00 AM
This guy is advertising these kits with "ADR Compliance available on 6psi kits".
They look half good value if (as advertised) they can make 400fwkw out of an unopened LS1 :goodjob:

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/SUPERCHARGER-KIT-VORTECH-LS1-5-7L-SS-HSV-VT-VX-VY-HOLDEN-COMMODORE-400KW-NEW-/221062769191?pt=AU_Car_Parts_Accessories&hash=item33785e2a27

SilverVH
01-08-2012, 01:22 PM
AFAIK whilst the basic kit might be ADR complianced on their test vehicle, the kit you buy does not come with the compliance (they are basically saying buy our kit and you won't have any hassles getting it complied.)

You will need to submit the vehicle for an IM240 or euro emmissions test prior to ADR compliance depending on the vehicle date of manufacture. In Melbourne this is done at Vipac in Port Melbourne. Once you have passed the emmissions, ADR compliancing is basicially a checklist of all the Australian Design Rules. Once this is done it is a straight forward affair.

Things to note:

E85 is the easiest way to pass the IM240/Euro III/IV test.
Once the vehicle is ADR complied it must stay that way or you risk getting defected. For example if you submit the vehicle for ADR compliance with a 20" rim with 275/30 tyre, then it will be complied with this tyre. If you change to an 18" wheel and tyre combination you can get defected.

To the OP, get the vehicle ADR complied and that way there is no hassles, then go crazy once you have saved again ;)

seedyrom
01-08-2012, 04:50 PM
They can't defect what they can't catch :burnout: