PDA

View Full Version : LS2 - 10k report



jed55
16-04-2005, 02:44 PM
Okay, the 10k mark has come and gone so I thought I would share my experience so far with those interested.

Enhancments
tinted windows
sunroof
mobile phone car kit
HSV sill plate covers
replaced front door speakers with Alpine SPS - 170a's and added Alpine SPE - 6903's mounted in the rear parcel shelf.

Modifications
None as yet. I'm waiting for ls2 edit.

The Experience
In a word.....fabulous. The car is everything that I hoped it would be and somewhat more.

Brief history.. I traded a vx berlina super 6 and a vt2 clubby to get the z. I loved the comfort and luxury of the berlina (a good sleeper too) and the raw animal acts of the clubby. Had the best of both worlds, so I thought. However guess which set of keys I picked up 90% of the time when going out. The clubby of course, So the poor old berlina was left languishing most of the time. Sad waste of a nice car. I decided to sell the berlina and mod up the clubby.

That is until one evening that we stopped at Zupps because my mate wanted to have a look at the new astra. She had recently got one of the old ones and wanted to compare. As we walked past the Hsv showroom there was a new Impulse Blue z glistening under the lights looking at me seemingly saying "you really want me, don't you". Well, no, I didn't really. Very happy with mine and was going to cash up and mod it up (bloody ls1 fever).

Decided that I may as well have a look at one and see what all the fuss over the ls2 was about. Firstly though I had a look at what the dark side had to offer but wasn't overly impressed. Nice cars but didn't feel any emotional connection with them and didn't seem to offer any performance advantage over what I had, although ride was good, and that exhaust note...

Back to Zupps, drove the ls2. Liked it, but wasn't overwhelmed. Definitely quicker, but not the great leap forward I was expecting after being fueled up on journalistic ravings. However I did feel the connection that was missing when testing the dark side. After much deliberation over the pros and cons of modding the ls1 versus going for the ls2, I decided to go ls2 even though I knew the modded ls1 would be quicker than the stock ls2.

Deal was done and a week later drove away in my new shiny impulse blue clubby, while, I admit, shedding some tears for the old one. Loved that car.

Okay, enough of that, on to the new car.

Mechanically it has been faultless. Finish is good and the two faults, missing seat rail cover and fault in the leather on the steering wheel were corrected, no problems. No squeaks or rattles and everything fits as it should.

Once I got it into my normal driving regime I soon discovered that the ls2 does have more on offer than the old one. Power is significantly better lower in the rev range, the suspension is intially softer giving a more comforatble ride for normal driving but plants nicely and drives out of corners better. Maybe I'm too insensitive but I don't notice any real difference with the fly by wire throttle.

Around the 7.5k - 8k mark it felt as though someone had flicked a switch in the computer or something as the improvement in power was very noticeable. In past posts I have mentioned how the traction control was virtually unnoticed, allowing adequate wheelspin on hard launches with a healthy chirp into 2nd (a4, by the way). Now, the launches feel very similar but when it hits 2nd it wheelspins rather than chirps and you really feel it pulling the power out till acceptable traction is regained. It's nothing like the crash, bang and epileptic throttle and total power shutdown of old. Far more subtle and you don't lose drive. I also notice the trac warning flash on tightish corners when giving it more than a tickle, but without actually feeling any intervention. Wet roads aren't as demanding as they were in the old clubby but are still very interesting with the trac control in demand for even the mildest touch.

Fuel consumption has been brilliant for me. Average over 10k has been a touch under 13l/100km. Compared to my old clubby which gave around 17l/100km in the same driving conditions. Hell, I was happy with that as the super 6 rarely bettered 15.5l/100km, but the ls2 is an economy car by comparison. Assuming $1 per litre for pulp, I've saved $400 in fuel costs, which would be more in reality as I haven't seen it that price for a while.

Interior comfort is good. The seats are softer in the bolsters and they seem to be a litle bit wider as I'm not held as closely across the shoulders as in the old one. Not as good for quick twisty stuff but the compromise suits me. I find that you don't slip around as much on the cloth seats compared to the leather in my daughter's vy2r8. The majority of passengers have commented how comfortable it is, being pleasantly surprised, having expected it to be a rip roaring hard riding monster. Then I give it a prod and they get whiplash.

The auto in the z differs from the old ones inasmuch as when 1st gear is selected, it stays there, doesn't change into 2nd at peak revs like the old ones. No one told me this and as I was in the habit of leaving it in first for hard launches in the old cars, the first time I tried it in the z I got quite a surprise, hit the limiter at 80kmh, forward motion came to such an abrubt halt the inertia belts locked as I was thrown forward. Ouch!!! The changes feels similar to the old one when it was in power mode. Changes are positive, can be a litlle jerky going 1-2 on light throttle. Overall I feel it is an improvement as it drives similarly to the old ones' normal mode when just tootling about and when you want some action it drives like the old power mode. I guess the improved computer management works it all out now so there is no need to manually switch it.

Servicing has been basically non events. Everything asked for has been done without any fuss or bother. I had dragged the front spoiler off on one of those damn car park cement blocks and I couldn't get it to stay hooked up so I asked for it to be fixed up at the service. Was told that the clip would need replacing as they are designed to break away rather than break off the bar. Only $7 to replace. No problem. When I picked it up I was told that the old clip was reusable so was put back in. No charge. Now I know that is only a small thing, but it does it does give confidence that if anything more major happens down the track it will be dealt with fairly. Lets face it, they could have put the clip back in, charged me for a new one plus labour and I wouldn't have known any different and I wouldn't have cared because I had ok'd the replacement. It's the little touches like that leave you feeling good. It's a pity more dealers didn't have that attitude rather than seeing the customer as a cash cow to be milked at every opportunity.

Also, when collecting my car, I was asked when I was going to do the headers and exhaust. Not if, but when. He then told me how good power gains are being made with just those mods. A most refreshing attitude I thought, encouraging mods, especially when I read in other posts of peoples problems with other dealers getting things like clutches legitmately fixed under warranty.

Was talking to my sales rep, Michael afterwards as well and he told me of one he is doing a deal on where they are fitting an exhaust prior to delivery. Promised to let me know when it comes so I can I have a listen. I intend to do my exhaust but want to hear some modded ls2s before making the plunge. Have only heard one which belongs to son in laws' friend and it sounds like crap. He's not happy with it either. It's loud and sounds okay when getting up it, although it's far louder than I want, but when cruising around it drones terribly. Bloody awful, ruins a good car. I actually like the sound of mine the way it is, so I'm not in any rush to change it.

Thank you to those who have read my ramblings to the finish. As you can no doubt tell, I love the car and extremely satisfied with the purchasing and after sales service. Can't stop smiling.

Cheers, John D

OLS108
16-04-2005, 04:23 PM
Top post Jed55 its good to see a bloke happy with his new car and being looked after by his dealer !
may the next 10,000 be as good as the first :D

Ralph1
16-04-2005, 05:41 PM
Mate sounds as if you have a nice car there, if at any time you want to get rid of it I will gladly swap my 82 Camira with 27rwkw 13" steelies and a six pack of your choice!!! :p :cool:

crisso
16-04-2005, 06:32 PM
Thanks for the read Jed. I signed the dotted line this morning for a Clubby of my own, should take delivery late this week, can't wait.

My dealer lent an LS2 to a mob for 7 days to refine an exhaust and extractor package, I can add this at any time whilst still covered under warranty. I will investigate after 3000kms and after I can hear such a system.

Keep on enjoying the Clubby.

crisso

HRT Stroker
16-04-2005, 06:36 PM
It's great when members take the time to write useful reviews like this one, well done. :thumbsup:

Rep added.... :D

seldo
16-04-2005, 06:38 PM
Excellent informative post jed55. Thanks - a good read, well written (must have taken you an hour..;) ) Glad to see you are stoked with your toy. :)

Tron2004
16-04-2005, 06:44 PM
The majority of passengers have commented how comfortable it is, being pleasantly surprised, having expected it to be a rip roaring hard riding monster. Then I give it a prod and they get whiplash.
Gotta tell ya.... Just luv the "whiplash" effect I have in my lil red beast. :D :D :D

frankdenial
16-04-2005, 07:49 PM
Agreed, great post & read, except now 'I Just want one'......guess I'll keep saving!

vuster
16-04-2005, 08:44 PM
Nice write up Jed. I agree with you as well. As for the exhaust, my holden dealer sells and fits Remus exhaust systems and I have been told that the systems have been approved by HSV and warranty won't be an issue. They are Cat back systems though. Not sure if it covers headers.

I have been talking to a guy in Melb and he's just received a LS2 remus cat back and is testing it before selling it. I will have it fitted on my car and will post the sound file so you guys can hear it.

Congrats Crisso. You finally got one.

crisso
17-04-2005, 09:00 AM
Congrats Crisso. You finally got one.
Yup, finally!

Not to hijack Jed's thread, I will post one of my own next week :D

Jed, your initial thread on the the LS2 combined with this one sealed the deal for me, I will have to buy you a beer for all your info.

crisso

jed55
17-04-2005, 12:51 PM
Yup, finally!

Not to hijack Jed's thread, I will post one of my own next week :D

Jed, your initial thread on the the LS2 combined with this one sealed the deal for me, I will have to buy you a beer for all your info.

crisso

Well done crisso. I hope your coming experiences are as good as mine have been.

Thanks to the rest of you guys for your positive responses to my post. It was hard to explain how pleased I am, not just with the car, but with the whole ownership experience (purchasing, dealer servicing, etc.) without coming over as a paid political advertisement.

Vuster, I am very interested in your feedback on the Remus system your getting. It's got to be better than what the son in law's mates sounds like.

Cheers, John D

SV8VY
18-04-2005, 08:37 AM
Good ...lengthy post.I cant believe I read the whole thing at 8 in the morning :lol:
Seriously good to see a full review but make sure you comment on any downsides if you encounter them in the future.
If everyone does this and warranty work can be performed before it happens.
You can now enjoy full synthetic oil in the beast next change and see if there is a difference.

kompiler
18-04-2005, 08:51 AM
Great post Jed,
As always a very well written article. I look forward to your next update ;)

I can only hope to have the same experience with my dealer. I'm yet to take it in for a service.

Regards

vuster
18-04-2005, 09:28 AM
I checked my rims yesterday and was surprised to find that the left back rim is already damaged. It was chipped all around the edges. Not sure how it happened though. I'm quite paranoid to push it around the corners now.

mid life
18-04-2005, 09:29 AM
Well done Jed55, like you the GTO just gets better every time I drive it, only 1500kls so far.

By the way had the sunroof fixed by the same guy that did yours and its a lot better now but he did say there is a new seal out that eliminates the wind noise and he will fit that at the first service.

Cheers
Jeff

chilly
18-04-2005, 10:42 AM
Well done Jed55, like you the GTO just gets better every time I drive it, only 1500kls so far.

By the way had the sunroof fixed by the same guy that did yours and its a lot better now but he did say there is a new seal out that eliminates the wind noise and he will fit that at the first service.

Cheers
Jeff

was that the guy i suggested ???

BEN 189
18-04-2005, 12:20 PM
Jed55

I would like to thank you for having made the time to wirte such a great post. I too would like to buy you a beer for helping to convince my good friend crisso in getting a HSV. Im just as excited as crisso about getting his car. :lol:

mid life
18-04-2005, 02:37 PM
was that the guy i suggested ???

I believe so, he does all the installs for the Brisbane dealers.

Many thanks

JaseR8
18-04-2005, 05:11 PM
Nice post Jed55.

I can concur with everything you said....mines just clocked 3000kms and it just gets better and better. The only complaint I have is the seats in the R8 aren't as bolstered on the sides as the seats in my old VXII R8. Driving at Wakefield Park was damn hard work and I had a harness in too. Oh, and the Pirelli's have a very soft outer edge....I ran a set of 18's with Bridestone S03's and the difference in track handling was amazing

Must also say a big thanks to Thunder (Greg @ Sureflo). He took my 6day old baby and gave it one of the best sounding cats-back I have heard, I have a GTP owner live across the street and the dude just stands there and drools everytime I drive down the street.

The dealer has been excellent, they wash the car for free every week for me, the service manager is happy for me to go mod-mad.

You are right about someone flicking the "Go-Baby" switch. Mine happened last week and fark me I've noticed a substantial performance improvement. 1-2 and 2-3 shifts are met with actual wheelspin which is almost lane-changing.

All I need now is a set of short 4-1 headers, remove the 2" front cat pipe, get a decent CAI from somewhere to replace the LS2 peashooter and get LS2edit done and the R8 will really come alive.

Damn now I'm homesick....sitting here in KL wishing I was out for a drive :(

crisso
18-04-2005, 08:30 PM
Nice post Jed55.
Must also say a big thanks to Thunder (Greg @ Sureflo). He took my 6day old baby and gave it one of the best sounding cats-back I have heard, I have a GTP owner live across the street and the dude just stands there and drools everytime I drive down the street.(
WOW - you don't muck around man...6 days old?!

have you got a thread describing your system? I would be very interested to read about it.

crisso

VU SS 50
18-04-2005, 09:58 PM
i've got the R8 Maloo and can't say the traction control button does a lot

2000 k's now and waiting big time for edit to arrive :P

vuster
19-04-2005, 09:35 AM
Yeah, I'm a bit concerned about my traction control button. I can manage to spin the wheels like crazy and get the car to fish tail with it on.

mid life
19-04-2005, 11:28 AM
Hey Jed55 and any of you other guys with LS2's do have any problems with flutuating temp gauges? Mine seems to move around a lot between 1/4 and half way between the 1/4 and 1/2 marks, never goes as far as 1/2 so I'm not getting an overheating problem, but the old VU was always rock solid once it reached temp. :confused:

BEN 189
19-04-2005, 11:34 AM
WOW - you don't muck around man...6 days old?!

have you got a thread describing your system? I would be very interested to read about it.

crisso

crisso, give it to next saturday and you will be able to here it on mine :D
JaseR8, did you get medium or loud??? Thunder is trying to convince me to get loud.

kompiler
19-04-2005, 01:34 PM
Hey Jed55 and any of you other guys with LS2's do have any problems with flutuating temp gauges? Mine seems to move around a lot between 1/4 and half way between the 1/4 and 1/2 marks, never goes as far as 1/2 so I'm not getting an overheating problem, but the old VU was always rock solid once it reached temp. :confused:

Mine sits on exactly 1/4 when cruising. When in heavy traffic and sitting still, it only moves about 1/8th toward the half way mark. As soon as it gets there, the fan kicks in and holds it. I've never seen it get to half way between 1/4 and 1/2 and I drive with one eye on temp, the other on speed, occasionally checking the road ahead. I did check the radiator the other day and was surprised to find it had dropped a fair bit. :(
Oil usage is still perfect and i'm going in for my 3k service this weekend.

The Warden
19-04-2005, 06:53 PM
Hey Jed55 and any of you other guys with LS2's do have any problems with flutuating temp gauges? Mine seems to move around a lot between 1/4 and half way between the 1/4 and 1/2 marks, never goes as far as 1/2 so I'm not getting an overheating problem, but the old VU was always rock solid once it reached temp. :confused:

No problems here, mine's the same as described by komplier.

Cheers,

Gordie

jed55
19-04-2005, 09:05 PM
Hey Jed55 and any of you other guys with LS2's do have any problems with flutuating temp gauges? Mine seems to move around a lot between 1/4 and half way between the 1/4 and 1/2 marks, never goes as far as 1/2 so I'm not getting an overheating problem, but the old VU was always rock solid once it reached temp. :confused:

Hi midlife. My temp gauge sits spot on the 1/4 mark normally. In heavy traffic I have seen it move about 2 widths of the needle over before the fans kick in, but they are kicking in and out all the time as I never turn the air off.

Just got back from the coast and it didn't move off 1/4 at all.

Had its first failure tonight. The cd stacker has died. Came up with a read error while playing and when I tried to unload the cd's when I got home I'm getting a mechanical failure error. Luckily there are only 2 in it but it looks like a trip to Zupps in the morning and test their servicing out again. Bugger.

Cheers, John D

jed55
19-04-2005, 09:36 PM
Nice post Jed55.

I can concur with everything you said....mines just clocked 3000kms and it just gets better and better. The only complaint I have is the seats in the R8 aren't as bolstered on the sides as the seats in my old VXII R8. Driving at Wakefield Park was damn hard work and I had a harness in too. Oh, and the Pirelli's have a very soft outer edge....I ran a set of 18's with Bridestone S03's and the difference in track handling was amazing

Must also say a big thanks to Thunder (Greg @ Sureflo). He took my 6day old baby and gave it one of the best sounding cats-back I have heard, I have a GTP owner live across the street and the dude just stands there and drools everytime I drive down the street.

The dealer has been excellent, they wash the car for free every week for me, the service manager is happy for me to go mod-mad.

You are right about someone flicking the "Go-Baby" switch. Mine happened last week and fark me I've noticed a substantial performance improvement. 1-2 and 2-3 shifts are met with actual wheelspin which is almost lane-changing.

All I need now is a set of short 4-1 headers, remove the 2" front cat pipe, get a decent CAI from somewhere to replace the LS2 peashooter and get LS2edit done and the R8 will really come alive.

Damn now I'm homesick....sitting here in KL wishing I was out for a drive :(
Hi JaseR8, I'm glad that someone else had noticed has picked up the sudden change in power as well. I thought it was my imagination the first time I noticed it.

Would love to hear what yours sounds like after Thunder's magic touch. Could you get a sound file of it at some stage? Looks like a road trip to Sydney may be in order in the future to get it done.

At least I won't go thirsty seeing a crisso and ben indicate that there are a few :cheers: on offer :D .

Cheers, John D

crisso
19-04-2005, 10:25 PM
Yeah champ, when you pop up, let us know...never know, I might book mine in at the same time, get a group discount ;)

JaseR8
20-04-2005, 02:03 PM
crisso, give it to next saturday and you will be able to here it on mine :D
JaseR8, did you get medium or loud??? Thunder is trying to convince me to get loud.

Sorry guys, been overseas so just catching up on old posts now. The Sureflo system on my car is medium/loud, I'm running hotdog style front mufflers and a larger rear resonator. It's definitely not as loud as my old R8, but it still has to have a few miles on it before I could really be sure.

The sound is not unlike the old Holden 220i strokers, it has a nice deep rumble to it.

Now I'm just waiting for a decent set of headers for it...

JaseR8
20-04-2005, 02:15 PM
WOW - you don't muck around man...6 days old?!

have you got a thread describing your system? I would be very interested to read about it.

crisso

Hi Crisso, there was a thread a few weeks ago describing the system, but not sure what the hell I called it.

As for it being 6days old it was going to be done the day I picked it up from the dealer but I got stuck at work :D It needed some noise, after driving my old R8 the stockie LS2 just sounded too tame for my liking.

I should be back in Sydney next week so it might be worth getting a cruise together so you can hear it for yourself. I tried doing a sound file, but at 15.8Mb zipped it's not real good for downloading - I'll have to try something else.

JaseR8
20-04-2005, 02:17 PM
Hey Jed55 and any of you other guys with LS2's do have any problems with flutuating temp gauges? Mine seems to move around a lot between 1/4 and half way between the 1/4 and 1/2 marks, never goes as far as 1/2 so I'm not getting an overheating problem, but the old VU was always rock solid once it reached temp. :confused:

Hi Midlife, my temp gauge sits in between 1/4 and 1/2 but doesn't move about too much.

My fuel gauge is the problem, for some reason it keeps going from F to E in a really quick fashion :D

Cat755
20-04-2005, 08:40 PM
Mine sits on exactly 1/4 when cruising. When in heavy traffic and sitting still, it only moves about 1/8th toward the half way mark. As soon as it gets there, the fan kicks in and holds it. I've never seen it get to half way between 1/4 and 1/2 and I drive with one eye on temp, the other on speed, occasionally checking the road ahead. I did check the radiator the other day and was surprised to find it had dropped a fair bit. :(
Oil usage is still perfect and i'm going in for my 3k service this weekend.

Mine is the same, temp never moves above the 1/4 mark, although we don't have the heavy traffic out here and it is rarely sitting still :p .Even when running fairly quick on the open road during the day this summer, outside temps around 45 degrees,the gauge never moved. I've also had to add water to the radiator,twice-about 3/4 of a litre each time (second time this morning), must mention this to my dealer as there are no visible signs of where the loss is coming from. Apart from a small problem with the power steering everything else is perfect.
Great posts jedd55, hope your CD stacker is something simple and working now. Had a similar problem in the previous VX R8 and it required a new headunit and stacker to fix it :bash:
When talking to my service manager the other day he intimated that he has no problems with exhaust mods, engine back. If only I could convince the wife :box:

http://www.cardomain.com/memberpage/743724

Zaxss
22-04-2005, 09:23 PM
Thanks to the rest of you guys for your positive responses to my post. It was hard to explain how pleased I am, not just with the car, but with the whole ownership experience (purchasing, dealer servicing, etc.) without coming over as a paid political advertisement.

Vuster, I am very interested in your feedback on the Remus system your getting. It's got to be better than what the son in law's mates sounds like.

Cheers, John D

Hi Jed

I just bought a phantom VZ Clubsport A4 a month ago and have now covered 2000 km...........I still have this silly grin on my dial everytime I get into the car or someone talks to me about it. Now I am certainly no boy racer, but I can't help but enjoy the rush when the pedal is pushed a little harder. My previous ride was a VX SS.....very good, but doesn't hold a candle to the power, comfort and sheer pleasure of the Z. When I test drove a Senator, it was the smooth progressive take off power and transmission (A4) that sold me. It felt so totally different.

Like you I have had an extremely pleasant and certainly enjoyable transition into my Clubbie. My dealer was thorough and very helpful in making sure I was totally happy with the car and service. I had the SS serviced by him previously, so I am already sure that he will look after me - he also previously sold me headers etc for the SS and had no issues with warranty. Seem that this sort of dealer is getting rarer.

Bugger me if I didn't scrape the rear left rim as well......maybe it sticks out a little further.....in fact I get a little body rub with the left rear when I hit a bump with a couple of passengers in the back. Warranty job number 1.

The only other one is when doing a slow turn (U-turn like) I get a vibration through the steering as if the power steering pump is turning over too slow and you can fell each power stroke......warranty check out.

My temp guage is a steady as a rock at 1/4, no matter what the outside temp.....sound like the varying 1/4 - 1/2 could be a sender unit.

So far so good......about as economical as the SS (~ 12.8L/110k) certainly more fun.....am more than happy and can only recommend one to anyone thinking about buying a Z Clubsport.

Would be great to see how the exhaust mods work out. I am not after the power (yet), but would kill for a lovely deep throbbing note. My dealer has been removing the large rear resonator......don't know whether he inserts anything, but says the note is great. Will check it out.

Thanks for your great report and hope to see a follow up. I'll also contribute as miles race by.

Cheers
Zac

jed55
25-04-2005, 12:52 AM
Good to hear that your having a good time with your new toy, Zaxss. Glad to hear that you have a good dealer too. They seem to be a rare breed these days.

What is it with the left rear wheel? I've gutter rashed mine slightly. Haven't had a problem with rubbing though. My power steering gets a bit grumbly when its held on full lock, but every other car I've had with ps has been the same. I haven't noticed what you've described.

The problem with my stacker miraculously disappeared the next morning when I tried it again before taking it in. Still going okay now, but after failing once I don't have a lot of confidence in it so it will go back the next time it dies. I've got an Alpine hu from the old clubbie sitting in the cupboard which I might be putting in sooner than intended. I really want to keep the stock look and the sound has improved nicely after replacing the speakers, but they would like a bit more power driving them. Don't want to drown out the ls2 though :D .

Cheers, John D

roger440
25-04-2005, 07:39 AM
Jed, don't know what the weather is like where you are (better than here i'm sure) but i'm over in england, and my CD stacker does exactly as you describe on damp/misty mornings. Fault always clears if i run the air con for a few minutes.

Been like it since new. Can only assume a build up of condensation on the discs or the reader is the cause.

Hope this helps

caphsv
21-05-2005, 05:40 PM
Nice post Jed55,

I was in at Zupps on Friday for a look. I didn't reliase how much I missed my R8... I just hope the build quality is better than the VY... Also with my 4.8 auto Patrol using 18 Ltr/100 on the hwy and 24+ Ltr/100 around town! :mad:
I might be back in a HSV sooner than I planned!