PDA

View Full Version : The Herd + Redgum



Cainer
20-03-2006, 09:10 PM
Now alot of you would remember the original Redgum song "I was only 19", the aussie hiptop group "The Herd" did an amasing job re-telling the story in a more 21 century way.


The old Redgum song 'I was only 19' recently covered by The Herd. It's a song about a Vietnam veteran who was conscripted and sent off to war at the age of 19, who returns to live in a society that doesn't understand and doesn't care about what he's been through. It's a story that resonates with many listeners to this program, who's fathers served in Vietnam, many whom still have difficult relationships with their Dads, who were so damaged by not only their experience of war, but the hostile reception they received when they got back. It is a timely reminder too, of what happens when you send soldiers into battle and the damage it causes down the generations. We live in a time when politicians, who've never seen action themselves, are sending more Australians off to fight wars in foreign nations. The Herd have just put together a film clip of 'I Was Only Nineteen'. It was finished this week and Ali Benton has been able to get access to the filmmakers, the band members, the writer of the song John Schuman, and some of the veterans themselves.


You can view the video clip here, (Click on >> Play Now) - http://brokenyellow.com/theherd.html

-

Steve Cannane from JJJ hosts a daily program called "Hack", they did a 30 minute story on the background of the song and information from Redgum and the vets. Defantely a story worth hearing, this can be heard - http://www.abc.net.au/triplej/hack/notes/mp3s/19.mp3

IIV8II
21-03-2006, 08:57 AM
yeah top song - both versions

Cainer
21-03-2006, 09:30 AM
i was referring to HipHop in the first line, not HipTop

Avalanche
21-03-2006, 09:42 AM
Just my opinion, they shouldnt have touched it. Dont try & pretend to show what it was like in such a cheap way. That film clip was crap. The real footage shows it etched on their faces. Degrades the vets.

stealthvz
21-03-2006, 04:43 PM
Just my opinion, they shouldnt have touched it. Dont try & pretend to show what it was like in such a cheap way. That film clip was crap. The real footage shows it etched on their faces. Degrades the vets.

Yeah I don't really agree with you, on the show they spoke to a couple of vets and they love the fact that this 'story' was being told to young people and making them relise what they weht through!

But each to their own!

I like the herd's version, but it was better when they did it on 'like a version' segment on triple J, sounded heaps better!

matty s
21-03-2006, 05:12 PM
Totally agree with stealhvz,sounded heaps better on "Like a Version"

Cainer
21-03-2006, 07:28 PM
Just my opinion, they shouldnt have touched it. Dont try & pretend to show what it was like in such a cheap way. That film clip was crap. The real footage shows it etched on their faces. Degrades the vets.


Have a listen to - http://www.abc.net.au/triplej/hack/notes/mp3s/19.mp3

this is the news report that was broadcasted on JJJ.

pagey
21-03-2006, 07:52 PM
haven't heard the "new" version yet.. don't really intend on listening to it either.

The old man is a Vietnam Vet.. and that song makes me shiver and a tear every time I hear it.

Leave it be.

Smitty
21-03-2006, 08:07 PM
haven't heard the "new" version yet.. don't really intend on listening to it either.
The old man is a Vietnam Vet.. and that song makes me shiver and a tear every time I hear it.
Leave it be.

I hafta agree.
as one who missed out (coz my date did not come out of the barrel)
and one who had mates who did go and fight..and get injured and
scarred
and who today.....won't talk about the mud and the blood
imho, no cover version of the original should have been done. :vpo:

wot next?..someone trying to do another version of Khe Sanh :mad:

as Pagey sez...leave it be

Cainer
21-03-2006, 08:16 PM
I hafta agree.
as one who missed out (coz my date did not come out of the barrel)
and one who had mates who did go and fight..and get injured and
scarred
and who today.....won't talk about the mud and the blood
imho, no cover version of the original should have been done. :vpo:

wot next?..someone trying to do another version of Khe Sanh :mad:

as Pagey sez...leave it be


I can appreciate you guys thoughts on the herd retake, but it might be worth having a listen to the hack report. A interesting insite on the orginal redgum song and the sole surivors input on the redgum plus the herd take.

A intersting report to say the least, and i was not trying to touch on some unhealed scares.. but even though its a retake it still brings the original story across.. IMO


http://www.abc.net.au/triplej/hack/notes/mp3s/19.mp3

lautray
21-03-2006, 08:43 PM
Triple j did a good feature on it :thumbsup: .

Yoda
21-03-2006, 10:18 PM
When I first heard the remake, I thought "What have they done. Its crap".
Then I listened to it a couple of times and heard the JJJ feature about the making of the song and the interviews with the parties invloved.
I have changed my mind. I will always love the original but they have brought a new audience to some of the issues issues that surround the viewtiam war and our vetrans.
Listen to the 30 minute JJJ segement. It is really interesting, especially the positive thoughts of the vetrans.
Lest we forget

Cheers