Holden/HSV V8 engine/performance questions

[Sarkis_28]

If I were to buy either of the two for performance and looks, which would be the way to go?

Would a HSV VT (Series 2) Clubsport 5.7L 250kw beat say a VX SS or VY SS commodore in a straight line drag?


Also, how much faster is the VT GEN III Clubsport compared to the 5.0L VT Clubsport?

And finally, would a enthusiast prefer to get a 6SPD Manual V8 or 4SPD Auto?

Thanks Fellas

[KeenGolfer]

There would be nothing in it in a straight line between VX/VY SS and VT Clubbie. Would come down to driver skill. You wouldn't buy any of these based on performance over the other as they're all basically the same with a few mods they'll pump out 300 fwkw. Personally out of those a VY SS would be the better buy.

Gen III should be a lot faster than a 5.0 VT Clubbie, especially once you get a tune.

If you want the quickest possible car in a staight line the auto seems to be the way to go, but you need it calibrated by a tuner to get the most out of it.

[dabadbaz427]

SS Commodore with M6... Auto will break your neck and is sooo boring do drive.

... If ya want my tip, go giv'em all a punt and see which one you fancy

[Ghosn]

My pick would be a VY SS M6 without question. The others are not even comparable.