Page 7 of 9 FirstFirst ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 LastLast
Results 91 to 105 of 126

Thread: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

  1. #91
    IJ.'s Avatar
    IJ. is offline One of the Top Contributors to the Forum Last Online: 02-08-2018 @ 01:19 PM
    Member Since
    Mar 2009
    Location
    The Bush
    Posts
    7,760

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    Best rib supercharger belt i have ever used is a Goodyear GATORBACK belt. It also has a 45 deg cross cut across the normal belt grooves. This allows the air to escape between the pulley and the belt, stopping the belt lifting off the pulley. This is why you hear belt slip at high RPM only, the air is getting under the belt.
    Using a gator belt i have been able to run an extra 2-3 psi on a 6-8 and 10 rib belt system, after changing the blower pulley only.
    Tightening the blower belt like a piano string only damages the blower bearings.
    6 rib good for 6-7psi
    8rib 7-9psi
    10 rib 8-12 psi.
    The best drive is Gilmer or tooth drive, but hard on the pulleys and belts.
    x2 on the Gatorback, noticably quieter at idle as well

  2. #92
    white lie is offline Considerable Contributor to the Forum Last Online: 15-05-2024 @ 08:24 PM
    Member Since
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Perth
    Posts
    3,586

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    You have half got it, as the rotors turn and start to compress the air shoots down the rotor face to the exit into the manifold. As the air compresses in produces heat, heat is produced by resistance. The less resistance you have the less heat you produce therefore less load on the engine. The rotors are more efficiant, because it takes less effort to turn the blower. The cooler air you introduce into the manifold the more free horsepower you make, and the less load needed on the engine, because you dont have to turn you charger (as in boost) as hard. Introduction to intercoolers. Now theres another story.
    Just remember you are compressing air, the more boost the more resistance,the more load on the engine. In all my dyno testing and et testing i could not measure any differance between front drive and rear drive PD chargers.
    I understand why or how there have been improvements in blower design due to newer, more efficient rotors but surely you can't tar all blowers using these rotors with the same brush.

    I can think of at least 5-6 different designs of blowers with the same displacement that use the same rotors. I can't see how they can all behave exactly the same under the same conditions (say if you take one off and bolt the other on to the same engine combo and run the same size pulley). Blowers (and intercooler setups for that matter as you need to compare a complete kit) can surely all have different rates of efficiency, which will equate to different boost levels in to the motor. Whether this is justifiable to the consumer or not, I don't know... I'm happy with my setup so won't be forking out for the latest and greatest but if I was to buy another vehicle, I would.

    Generally, all the WP blowers that I have seen have much lower results (torque, power and MPH) than the equivalent Maggie or Harrop, yet they use the same Eaton rotors.
    Last edited by white lie; 07-01-2013 at 07:55 AM.

  3. #93
    Ken's Avatar
    Ken is offline Forum Contributor Last Online: 13-04-2023 @ 10:40 AM
    Member Since
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    1,289

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Hmmm ...
    I think it is time to inject some clarification to ensure that the facts about the Magnuson Heartbeat supercharger are not confused by other products on the market.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    This is not a new supercharger but a very good sales stunt, There is one world manufactuer that produces the rotors for neally all the PD superchargers in the world. ...
    Eaton does produce more than 95% of all supercharger rotor groups, and >99% of OEM rotor groups ... however that does not mean by any imaginary stretch that all superchargers created from those rotors are equal. Eaton's own testing very clearly proves that.
    A supercharger is not just the rotors - there are many things that contribute to the effectiveness of the system. Some of the advantages of Heartbeat's performance & efficiency over other systems include:
    • Large & unrestricted intake, negating depression between the throttle plate & the rotors.
    • Unique purpose-designed "Pentalobe" coupling for improved input-shaft to rotor connection.
    • The (large) bypass port is not restrictive to flow in either low-flow or high-flow situations.
    • Rotor intake-port timing is optimised.
    • Heartbeat has a non-torturous and more laminar pre-rotor airflow path.
    • Rotor discharge port timing and shape are optimised.
    • The discharge port is not crowded by charge-air-coolers (CAC's) or other casting surfaces.
    • A large pre-CAC plenum ensures more even distribution of charge through the coolers.
    • The unique dual CAC's ensure superior cooling without creating excessive pressure drop.
    • The port seperators create ideal boundaries to ensure cross-port contanination is eliminated without introducing the restrictions of "runners".


    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    ... What is the differance between a 671 or a 871 blower, what is the differance between a half screw a single screw and a twin screw Blower or in drag racing a PSI blower? ...
    Interesting comments, but of little relevance to Heartbeat as it is none of the above.
    Heartbeat is a hybrid Roots-based TVS2300 ... not a screw of any sort.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    ... If it is driven from the front or rear of the blower is of no concern, the rotors must turn,how its done does not effect boost, if you experiance belt slip, that is another issue. If we want to expore i ammore that happy toshare my experiance's. Good thread.
    It would be nice if the method of turning the rotors had no effect, but the parasitic loss of the supercharger system is definantely effected by the drive method. A transfer shaft system will take more energy to turn than a direct-drive system - or at least until the laws of friction and inertia are re-written. The mass & moment of inertia affect accelleration/decelleration as well as the overall parasitic loss. Heartbeat's cartridge-drive input system is lighter and has less inertia than any other system currently available.
    Additionally, the drive method can definately affect the potential for good efficiency as some (not Heartbeat) front-drive systems are quite restrictive and create massive turbulence currents for the air entering the rotors. Heartbeat's design ensures the a nice flow-path while enjoying the benefits of a front-drive system.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    ... as the rotors turn and start to compress the air shoots down the rotor face to the exit into the manifold. As the air compresses in produces heat, heat is produced by resistance ...
    This statement is true for twin-screw compressors, but not correct for hybrid-Roots air-pumps like Heartbeat. There is no compression taking place within the supercharger rotor chambers - the air is not compressed until it exits the discharge port and enters the manifold. A twin-screw generates compression & heat with every turn regardless of whether the engine needs boost or not, whereas the hybrid-Roots will only create boost when it is needed, which is part of the reason the system is so efficient.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    ... In all my dyno testing and et testing i could not measure any differance between front drive and rear drive PD chargers.
    We look forward to your testing of Heartbeat. Every test done so far (locally & by independant workshops in the USA) have shown the prototype Heartbeat to be significantly better - and on back-to-back, same-engine, same-dyno tests. Further testing of the production system is scheduled and the results will be published.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    ...Tightening the blower belt like a piano string only damages the blower bearings. 6 rib good for 6-7psi. 8rib 7-9psi. 10 rib 8-12 psi.
    The best drive is Gilmer or tooth drive, but hard on the pulleys and belts.
    The belt-wrap shown on the images of the VCM VE is not indicative of the final system. In fact, the entire system shown is pre-production and does not include all of the features of the final release. Even so, because the design has been very focussed on eliminating parasitic loss ... we have pulled >10psi without any noticable slippage even with the minimal wrap.
    When the full system is installed (as shown at SEMA), the belt wrap is very impressive.
    Although toothed belt drives eliminate slippage, the harmonics introduced are not kind to the supercharger.
    While overtightening the drive belt should always be avoided, the Heartbeat cartridge-drive & Pentalobe coupling system ensure that rotor bearings are isolated from any belt tensioning misadventure.
    Last edited by Ken; 07-01-2013 at 08:21 AM.
    Turbos are OK, but I prefer to be Oversize, Stroked & Blown!

  4. #94
    Woodchukka is offline Fair Contributor to the Forums Last Online: 29-05-2019 @ 02:24 PM
    Member Since
    May 2011
    Location
    Hunter Valley
    Posts
    1,877

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Interesting read. Cleared up some things I have heard over the years.

  5. #95
    IJ.'s Avatar
    IJ. is offline One of the Top Contributors to the Forum Last Online: 02-08-2018 @ 01:19 PM
    Member Since
    Mar 2009
    Location
    The Bush
    Posts
    7,760

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Ken: How does the Edelbrock E-Force/Harrop Stealth Force stack up against the Heartbeat seeing as they share a lot of the features you've mentioned above?

  6. #96
    Ken's Avatar
    Ken is offline Forum Contributor Last Online: 13-04-2023 @ 10:40 AM
    Member Since
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    1,289

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Quote Originally Posted by IJ. View Post
    Ken: How does the Edelbrock E-Force/Harrop Stealth Force stack up against the Heartbeat seeing as they share a lot of the features you've mentioned above?
    There are very few similarities between the Edelbrock, HTV, & Heartbeat. The bullet pointed features above are some of the key differences.
    Turbos are OK, but I prefer to be Oversize, Stroked & Blown!

  7. #97
    Wonky's Avatar
    Wonky is offline One of the Top Contributors to the Forum Last Online: 07-05-2025 @ 10:41 PM
    Member Since
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Officer
    Posts
    15,173

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Quote Originally Posted by ls2 cruiser View Post
    What do you think wonky?
    Sorry, I am far from knowledgeable on superchargers except for the knowledge that while I'd love one, with my disabilities I'd probably be dead in less than a week.........

    I'd put a lot of faith in what Ken (ex Harrop) says as he seems to really know his stuff, as well as taking note of what tbs23 says as he seems to have a lot of practical experience with them, though I know nothing of his background.

  8. #98
    tbs23 is offline Rarely Contributes to the Forum Last Online: 08-01-2013 @ 07:53 PM
    Member Since
    Dec 2012
    Location
    brisbane
    Posts
    10

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    35 years in the performance and racing industry, TBS should give you a clue, Ken and i have discussed many a issues when he was working at Harrops, Ken we have spoken many a times about supercharger issues.I teach automotive engineering in QLD now.

  9. #99
    tbs23 is offline Rarely Contributes to the Forum Last Online: 08-01-2013 @ 07:53 PM
    Member Since
    Dec 2012
    Location
    brisbane
    Posts
    10

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Something i dug up so, everyone can read and understand put everyone in the picture,as so.
    Q: Does Eaton make aftermarket supercharger kits?
    A: Eaton only produces OEM (factory, from the dealer) type superchargers. The Eaton aftermarket business consists of 4 partner companies. These companies purchase certified components and internal sub-assemblies direct from Eaton (bearings, rotors, gears, and seals). These are the same internal components found in the Eaton OEM assemblies. The only difference is that each aftermarket partner company creates its own housing designs to fit the needs of the aftermarket applications. These housings are designed and tested in conjunction with Eaton to ensure proper specifications.
    Q: How do I get an Eaton aftermarket supercharger kit for my vehicle?
    A: Please contact one of the 4 Eaton aftermarket supercharger partner companies. Each company has unique application offerings.

    www.magnusonproducts.com
    1-805-642-8833
    www.harrop.com.au
    USA 1-269-660-1500
    Australia +61 3 9474 0900
    www.edelbrock.com
    1-800-416-8628
    www.roush.com
    1-800-59-ROUSH
    One manufacture of rotors supplies 90% of the rotors, and the rotors are what produce the boost. Is that right Ken?

  10. #100
    Ken's Avatar
    Ken is offline Forum Contributor Last Online: 13-04-2023 @ 10:40 AM
    Member Since
    Apr 2002
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    1,289

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Quote Originally Posted by tbs23 View Post
    ... One manufacture of rotors supplies 90% of the rotors, and the rotors are what produce the boost. Is that right Ken?
    The rotors are a key component, but no ... the rotors alone do not create the boost.
    Imagine a housing that has 1.0mm clearance to the rotors, or a CAC too close to the discharge port ... the boost will not be consistant with a correctly toleranced or designed system.
    I seem to recall that we (TBS23) once spoke of large throttle bodies, and I know that your expeience will confirm that even a change of throttle body will make a difference to the amount of boost a given supercharger can produce.
    Rotors contribute a great deal, but the entire system design & integration determines the boost, charge temperature, efficency etc.
    Refer to post 32 for clarification.
    Turbos are OK, but I prefer to be Oversize, Stroked & Blown!

  11. #101
    tbs23 is offline Rarely Contributes to the Forum Last Online: 08-01-2013 @ 07:53 PM
    Member Since
    Dec 2012
    Location
    brisbane
    Posts
    10

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    I agree but at the end of the day we are modifying the rest of the unit to gain the max rotor efficiency, do you remember when i re coated the rotors closed the housing clearances up and i dropped 15 deg manifold temp? I made more power and torque. Less heat
    I just not wanting to get too technical in this thread, so everyone can gain some knowledge. Not sales jargon. On saying that yes i would purchase the new kit because it has all the latest upgrades done. Good thread.

  12. #102
    k1w1noz is offline Occasional Contributor to the Forums Last Online: 25-02-2015 @ 09:25 AM
    Member Since
    Nov 2011
    Location
    Brisbane
    Posts
    125

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Quote Originally Posted by Drizt View Post
    Any rough $$ yet ?
    From the Corvette blogger website:

    The Magnuson Heartbeat TVS 2300 Supercharger kit is priced at $8,590 for the black powdercoated version or add $1,200 more for the polished unit. The new “Heartbeats” will be available in December 2012 for LS3 engines and then additional applications for other LS engines will be rolled out afterwards.

    Should be reasonably similar pricing here.........???

  13. #103
    white lie is offline Considerable Contributor to the Forum Last Online: 15-05-2024 @ 08:24 PM
    Member Since
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Perth
    Posts
    3,586

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Would be similar I'd imagine. Pretty much in the ball park of all the other kits anyway, so you'd expect it to be close

  14. #104
    BEARWOOD is offline Forum Contributor Last Online: 13-08-2016 @ 10:49 PM
    Member Since
    Jul 2005
    Location
    NSW
    Posts
    1,483

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.

    Whats news with these kits??

  15. #105
    ATOMIC MALOO R8's Avatar
    ATOMIC MALOO R8 is offline Considerable Contributor to the Forum Last Online: 12-02-2017 @ 04:55 PM
    Member Since
    Dec 2003
    Location
    cairns qld
    Age
    79
    Posts
    3,933

    Re: Interested In Superchargers?.....Read This.


Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •